filkertom: (okaytobetakei)
filkertom ([personal profile] filkertom) wrote2011-11-04 03:44 pm

That's All I Came Here For -- I've Already Got The Pajamas

I love my home state of Michigan. By and large, it's a lovely place. But our political system -- city, county, and state -- has gone down the effing tubes.

Brand-spankin'-new law. Hmmm. Maybe I shouldn't word it that way. Basically, it's a law with the ostensible purpose of providing more tangible protections against bullies and bullying. Y'know, like kids being beaten up by other kids.

Thing is, it's got loopholes.
The law includes a section noting it doesn't abridge First Amendment free speech rights or prohibit expression of religious or moral viewpoints — a provision Democrats fear could be used to justify harassment of gay, lesbian or transgender students.
It's worth it to follow some of the other links, including Joe My God and the straightforward Detroit News story.

Here's the thing: THERE ARE NO EXCUSES, EVER, FOR BULLYING.

You're worried about infringing on the rights of someone who is trying to harass, intimidate, threaten, and possibly physically harm someone? Fuck you. The old "your right to throw a punch ends at the tip of my nose" bit.

You say that there should be an exemption for those expressing their religious beliefs? Fuck you. We can play that game. Someone's First Amendment right to bully Someone Else because their faith "demands" it is cancelled out by Someone Else's First Amendment right protecting them from the government supporting any specific religion. Not to mention, y'know, the laws against assault. Oh, and, let's look at the tax status of any religion that says Thou Shalt Beat People Up Because They Make Us Feel All Squicky.

This is not merely a bad law, it's an asinine law. It literally provides a blueprint for how to get out of an accusation of bullying -- I Was Expressing My First Amendment Rights.

It's yet another of many, many examples of just how screwed up the people in charge really are.

I'm nowhere near ready to leave Michigan yet. But this pushes me one step closer.

Fuckers.

Hm.

[identity profile] crysthewolf.livejournal.com 2011-11-05 12:13 am (UTC)(link)
I have strong inclinations toward both protecting kids from bullying and protecting kids from others abusing the system to their advantage by invoking laws like this. Thus, I tend to sit on the fence when it comes to laws such as this being passed at all, as I always fear they will be abused by someone due to things like difficulty defining "bullying", etc. I have an innate fear of compromising rights of free speech, even for a good cause, because doing so can and does bite us in the ass in ways we don't always think about when we're feeling understandably passionate about things like this.

However, from what I've been able to find and read on the actual law itself... I think I have to call bullshit right along with you, Tom. There's no good reason for this provision. All it does is give bullies an out. Religious bullies, no less, which are some of the worst kinds. *grumble*